From our hand-tossed crusts to our one-of-a-kind toppings, every pie at Mellow Mushroom is made with care, creativity, and a whole lot of flavor. Pull up a chair and make yourself at home.
At Mellow Mushroom St Augustine – Murabella, we believe a great pizza starts long before the oven. It starts with the dough — stretched by hand, never rolled flat — and the toppings you'd actually be excited to put on yours.
Our kitchen is where creativity meets tradition. We source fresh ingredients, experiment with bold flavor combos, and bake every pie in a hot stone oven until the crust is golden and crisp. The result? A slice that feels like coming home.
It's not just what goes into the pie — it's the whole experience from the moment you walk in.
Our space is designed to feel like a second living room — relaxed, warm, and welcoming for families, friends, and anyone who just wants a great slice.
Every dough ball is hand-stretched, every topping placed with intention, and every pie baked until it's exactly right. No shortcuts, ever.
We're proud to be part of the St. Augustine community. Local ingredients, local partnerships, and a genuine love for the people who walk through our doors.
From the oven to your table — here's what awaits you at Mellow Mushroom St Augustine.
Nothing makes us prouder than hearing from the people who keep coming back.
"Hands down the best pizza in St. Augustine. The crust is perfect — crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. We come here every Friday night without fail."
"The atmosphere is so chill and the staff is incredibly friendly. It's our go-to spot for family dinners. The kids love it and so do we!"
"I'm a vegetarian and this place gets it. The Garden Veggie pie is loaded with fresh toppings and the garlic sauce base is incredible. So glad they're in the area."
We're right off FL-16 in the Murabella area — easy to find, impossible to forget.
Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni or something a little more adventurous, we've got a pie waiting for you. Call us or swing by — we save the best slice for last.
